The moment you realize a contractor isn’t working is usually not the moment they stop being useful. You’ve been compensating for gaps for weeks, spending extra time on revisions, rerouting tasks they weren’t executing well, managing the client relationship more tightly than you should have to. The decision to end the relationship is already overdue by the time you make it.
What prevents people from making it earlier is the same thing that makes the conversation hard: the relationship is personal, the person has put in real effort, and delivering bad news to someone who depends on your work for income feels unkind.
None of that changes the fundamental situation. Keeping a contractor who isn’t working in the role costs you more every week: in quality compromises, in your time covering gaps, in the opportunity cost of not having the right person in the role. The kindest thing you can do for both parties is end it cleanly and professionally, as soon as the decision is made.
Step 1: The Direct Conversation
The conversation happens in a live video call. Not in writing. A written termination feels cold, doesn’t allow the other person to respond, and removes the human element that makes difficult conversations livable.
Schedule the call with 24-48 hours notice. Don’t announce what it’s about in the scheduling message, that causes 48 hours of anxiety. A simple “I’d like to talk through how things are going and the path forward” is enough context without being deceptive.
In the call, be direct within the first 3 minutes. Don’t warm up for 20 minutes of normalcy before dropping the news. That approach is an act of self-protection, not kindness, it makes you comfortable at the expense of the other person’s time.
The script:
“I’ve been thinking carefully about how our work together is going, and I want to be honest with you. [Specific issue: the quality of the copy has consistently required more structural revision than I can sustain at project pace / the deadline reliability has been a persistent problem and it’s affecting my client relationships / the complexity of projects has grown beyond what the current engagement can cover]. I’ve made the decision to wrap up the engagement. I want to do this in a way that’s fair to you and smooth for both of us.”
Pause. Let them respond. Listen to the response. You don’t need to argue or defend. You’ve made the decision; the conversation is about how to execute it well, not whether to revisit it.
Step 2: The Transition Plan
The transition plan has two purposes: it gives the contractor a fair runway to replace the income, and it ensures your client work doesn’t have a gap during the offboarding period.
For most retainer relationships, 2-4 weeks is appropriate. Four weeks if the contractor has been with you 12+ months. Two weeks for shorter relationships or situations where quality problems make continuing difficult.
The transition plan should specify:
- What work continues during the transition. Typically: complete in-progress projects, no new project starts. Or: continue at reduced scope (the hours you’ve already committed to this month, nothing beyond).
- Knowledge transfer obligations. Any processes, access credentials, or project documentation they’re responsible for handing over before their last day.
- Communication to clients (if applicable). If the contractor has had direct client contact, coordinate how to communicate the change. This is your responsibility to manage, not theirs.
- The end date. A specific date, confirmed in writing in a brief follow-up email after the call.
The transition plan is not a favor, it’s a professional obligation. A contractor who has delivered work on your projects has earned a clean offboarding. Abrupt endings without transition plans make every other contractor on your team quietly wonder whether the same could happen to them. They watch how you handle departures as a signal of what to expect.
Step 3: The Severance Offer
Independent contractors are not legally entitled to severance in most jurisdictions. Offering it anyway is both the right thing to do and the professionally intelligent thing to do.
For contractors with 6+ months of consistent engagement: offer 1-2 weeks of their standard monthly pay. At $3,000/month, that’s $750-$1,500. The cost is modest relative to what you’ve spent on the engagement overall.
The offer matters because:
- It gives the contractor time to find replacement income without emergency
- It signals that the departure is about fit, not a punishment
- It preserves the professional relationship and keeps the door open to future collaboration
- It protects your reputation with other contractors who will likely hear about how you handled this
Frame the offer simply in the call: “I want to offer [X weeks] of additional pay as we close out the engagement. I’ll include that in the final invoice settlement.”
If the departure is the result of a serious failure, missed deadlines that damaged a client relationship, undisclosed work quality problems, a breach of the contract, a severance offer may not be appropriate. In those cases, fulfilling the contractual payment obligations (paying for completed work) is sufficient. Don’t offer severance for conduct failures.
Step 4: The Reference Offer
After giving your honest assessment of what went wrong, offer what you can honestly say. Not a full-throated endorsement if it isn’t warranted, but an honest and specific statement of the contractor’s genuine strengths.
“I’m happy to be a reference for your skills in [specific area] and your professionalism as a communicator. I’d describe the reason we’re wrapping up as the project direction shifting rather than anything about the quality of your collaboration overall. I can speak to that honestly if a prospective client reaches out.”
If the departure is due to performance rather than fit, you still have an obligation to honesty. What you can do: focus on genuine strengths, describe the end of the relationship neutrally (“the engagement scope shifted” or “the skill requirements evolved beyond the engagement’s original design”), and decline to volunteer damaging information you’re not asked directly about.
What you cannot do: fabricate enthusiasm for someone who damaged your client relationships or delivered chronically substandard work. That protects the contractor at the expense of the next business owner they work with. Be kind. Be honest. Don’t conflate the two.
The Conversation Mistakes That Cost You
Mistake 1: The email termination. Sending “I’ve decided to wrap up the engagement” in writing, with no call, is impersonal and doesn’t allow the contractor to ask questions or respond. It also looks bad to every other contractor on your team who finds out about it, which they will.
Mistake 2: The vague reason. “It’s not working out” or “the business is changing direction” when the actual reason is performance tells the contractor nothing useful and often leads to speculation about the real reason that’s worse than the truth.
Mistake 3: The delayed decision. Keeping a contractor who isn’t working because you don’t want to have the conversation costs you more each week and doesn’t improve. Make the decision when it’s clear, not when it becomes unavoidable.
Mistake 4: Cutting the conversation short. After delivering the news, rushing to end the call before the contractor has processed and responded is unkind. Give them 10-15 minutes to respond. Listen. You don’t need to reverse the decision, you need to give them space to react professionally.
Mistake 5: Badmouthing to other contractors. What you say about a departed contractor to current contractors tells them exactly how you’d speak about them if they left. Be professionally neutral. “It wasn’t the right fit” is both true and sufficient.
How you end a working relationship is part of your professional brand. Every contractor you’ve ever hired will eventually be asked about what it’s like to work with you. The answer they give is shaped significantly by how the relationship ended. Clean, honest, and graceful endings are a long-term investment in your reputation.
The Follow-Up Email
Within 24 hours of the conversation, send a brief written summary:
“[Name], as we discussed today, we’ll be closing out the engagement on [date]. Your work through [end date] will be compensated at your standard rate, plus [severance if offered]. Please send your final invoice by [date] and plan to transfer [specific files/access] to [person or system] by [date]. Thank you for the work you did on [specific projects]. I genuinely appreciate what you contributed and wish you well with what comes next.”
Keep it short. Acknowledge the work they did. Confirm the logistics. Close cleanly.
Ready to send stronger proposals?
Build, send, and track proposals in one place so follow-up is easier.
Start your free trial →
