Testimonials are your most credible marketing tool. A prospect scrolling your portfolio might not trust you. But they’ll trust another client saying you transformed their work. The hard part is asking without awkwardness. Here’s how to do it naturally.
Why You Need Testimonials
Testimonials are third-party proof. You saying you’re great doesn’t move people. Another client saying it is worth 100 ads. New prospects trust other clients more than they trust you.
They’re also specific proof. “She organized our chaotic process, saving us five hours weekly” beats “great to work with.” Specific testimonials convert.
The best ones mention a specific problem and how you solved it. “We couldn’t track proposals. Now we use Waco3 and know when clients open them. Follow-up time dropped in half.” That’s a testimonial that sells.
When to Ask
Ask within one week of project completion. Not immediately. Let them sit with the work for a few days and feel the results. But don’t wait two months. By then they’re focused on the next project, not how good working together was.
Ask when they’re happy. If final revisions went smooth and they approved enthusiastically, that’s your moment. If they’ve been quiet or seem lukewarm, wait. Don’t ask for a testimonial when they’re secretly disappointed.
Ask after they’ve used or seen results. If you handed off the work and they haven’t launched it yet, wait. Ask after it’s live and they can speak to impact.
The Testimonial Request Email
Subject: Quick Favor: Would You Share Your Experience?
Hi [Client Name],
I’m so glad [project name] is exceeding your expectations. I’d love to know if you’d be willing to share a short testimonial about the experience.
Here’s what I’m looking for: a sentence or two about the challenge you were facing, what we did together, and the impact it’s had. Specific details are better than generic praise. For example:
“Before working with [your name], our proposal process was a mess. People opened proposals but we had no idea when or if they were interested. Now we use [tool/process] and we can follow up at the right time. It’s cut our admin time in half and our close rate is up.”
Something like that. One or two sentences. You can write it however feels natural to you.
Would you be open to doing something like that? If so, I’ll send you a simple form to fill out.
No pressure if the timing doesn’t work.
Thanks.
[Your name]
Why This Works
It’s casual, not formal. Not a legal request. Just a quick favor.
It’s specific about what you want. Not “write a testimonial” but “tell me about the problem, what we did, and the impact.” That structure helps them write.
It includes an example. They know exactly what length and tone you want. This increases the chance they’ll do it.
It’s brief. You’re not asking for an essay. Just a sentence or two.
It gives an out. “No pressure if the timing doesn’t work.” Removes guilt and makes yes more likely.
The Follow-Up
If they say yes, send them a simple form or Google Doc with those three prompts:
- What challenge were you facing?
- How did we work together to solve it?
- What’s the impact now?
They fill it in and send it back. Takes them 10 minutes max.
If they send something that’s perfect, use it as is. If it’s close but needs editing, run it by them. “I made a small edit to clean it up. Does this still feel right to you?” Most people are fine with that.
If they say no, don’t push. Just say “no problem, thanks anyway.” Their answer is final.
Where to Use Testimonials
Put them on your website. Not just on a testimonials page. Put relevant testimonials next to the service. Proposal tracking testimonials go near the proposal tracking section.
Use them in proposals. When a prospect asks about experience, include a relevant testimonial from a similar client. “I worked with [similar company] and helped them [result].”
Use them in sales conversations. When a prospect hesitates, mention a client with a similar problem. “I just finished a project with another [industry] client with the same concern. Here’s how we solved it.”
Use them in emails. Following up with a prospect, reference a testimonial from a similar client. “I saw you’re in the [industry]. I recently finished a project with another [industry] company facing a similar challenge.”
Getting Better Testimonials Over Time
Your first testimonials are good. Your fifth will be better. You’ll learn what questions get the best answers. You’ll learn which clients give specific feedback.
After a handful of testimonials, you can be selective. You’ll notice patterns in what moves prospects. Lean into those.
The best testimonials always mention:
- A specific problem they had
- What you did differently
- A measurable or observable result
Push clients gently toward those details. “I’d love to know specifically how the work changed things. Numbers, hours saved, revenue impact, anything concrete helps.”
The Permission Question
Always ask permission before using testimonials publicly. Even if they said yes to writing one, confirm they’re okay with it on your website or in a case study. Some are comfortable with text but not their name. Some don’t want photos. Ask.
Once you have permission, you’re set. You’ve got third-party proof. Use it.
The best testimonial isn’t the nicest compliment. It’s the one that tells the story of what you solved and the real impact it had.
Related: Client Offboarding Email: What to Say at the End of a Project
Ready to send stronger proposals?
Build, send, and track proposals in one place so follow-up is easier.
Start your free trial →
