People use “freelancer” and “self-employed” as if they’re different things. Socially, there’s a distinction—freelancers take project-based work, self-employed people might run a shop or practice. The IRS doesn’t care about the distinction. What matters is your business structure.
Understanding why the terms get conflated—and where the real differences lie—helps you make smarter decisions about how you set up your business and, eventually, how you can reduce what you owe.
How the IRS classifies work
The tax code cares about one question: are you an employee or are you not?
Employees have taxes withheld, receive W-2s, and pay only half of FICA (Social Security and Medicare taxes).
Everyone else who earns income through personal services—freelancers, independent contractors, sole proprietors, consultants—is generally self-employed for tax purposes. They receive 1099-NEC forms (if paid $600+), pay both halves of SE tax, and file Schedule C.
Whether you call yourself a freelance designer, an independent contractor, a self-employed consultant, or a solo practitioner, you’re filing the same forms and paying the same rates.
Where real differences appear: business structure
The structure you choose to operate under can change your tax treatment—even if you’re doing the same work.
Sole proprietor (default for most freelancers): All income is personal income. SE tax applies to all net earnings above $400. Simple to set up, no separate business tax return.
Single-member LLC: By default, taxed identically to a sole proprietor. The LLC gives you legal liability protection but doesn’t change your taxes. You still file Schedule C.
S-corporation (or LLC taxed as S-corp): Here’s where the tax difference appears. You pay yourself a “reasonable salary” as an employee—SE tax applies only to that salary. Remaining profits are distributed and are not subject to SE tax. The catch: you have payroll, a corporate return, and more complexity.
Partnership or multi-member LLC: Partners pay SE tax on their distributive share of business income. More complex than sole proprietorship, but allows you to share profits and losses.
S-corp taxation is the most common structure freelancers use to reduce SE tax—but it’s typically only worth the added complexity and cost above $60,000–$80,000 in annual net profit.
The 15.3% self-employment tax in plain terms
When you work as an employee, your paycheck has Medicare and Social Security withheld at 7.65%. Your employer matches that 7.65%. You never see the employer half.
When you’re self-employed, there’s no employer. You pay both halves: the full 15.3%. On $80,000 in net self-employment income, that’s $12,240 in SE tax alone—before income tax.
The partial offset: you can deduct half of the SE tax (the “employer” equivalent portion) when calculating your adjusted gross income. So on $80,000 net, you deduct about $6,120, reducing the taxable income slightly.
Business expenses reduce both taxes
Legitimate business expenses reduce your net self-employment income—which reduces both income tax and SE tax. This is why tracking expenses matters more for freelancers than for employees.
Deductible expenses include software (project management, design tools, invoicing tools), home office costs, professional development, health insurance premiums, and retirement contributions. Every dollar in documented deductions reduces your SE tax by 15.3 cents and your income tax by whatever your marginal rate is.
W-2 vs. 1099: the practical difference
If a client issues you a W-2, you’re an employee—they withheld taxes and paid the employer’s share of FICA. If they issue a 1099-NEC (or pay you under $600 with no form), you’re responsible for your own taxes.
Misclassification—where a company treats workers like employees in practice but pays them as contractors—has significant legal consequences for the company. As a worker, if you believe you’re being misclassified, the IRS has a Form SS-8 process to request a determination.
Should you form an LLC or S-corp?
For most freelancers just starting, the answer is: not immediately.
Sole proprietorship is the simplest starting point. As income grows:
- LLC: Add one when you want legal liability protection or when clients or contracts require it. No tax change.
- S-corp election: Consider when your net profit consistently exceeds $60,000–$80,000. The SE tax savings can outweigh the costs of payroll processing and a corporate tax return (Form 1120-S). Work with a CPA to model whether it makes sense for your situation.
The “right” structure is the one that fits your current income and complexity tolerance—and changes as your business grows.
Ready to send stronger proposals?
Build, send, and track proposals in one place so follow-up is easier.
Start your free trial →
